When analyzing the relationship between a planet and its dispositor, both tatkaalik maitri (temporary friendship) and the strength of the dispositor need to be weighed carefully. In the case you mentioned—Scorpio ascendant, Venus in Dhanu (Sagittarius), and Jupiter (its dispositor) placed in Makar (Capricorn)—we’re seeing a classic conflict.

While Venus enjoys tatkaalik maitri with Jupiter, Jupiter itself is debilitated in Capricorn. This creates a scenario where the planet (Venus) might have directional or situational support but lacks foundational strength due to its weak dispositor. A debilitated dispositor like Guru in Makar will certainly dilute the positive outcomes Venus might offer, especially in Venus-related matters like relationships, creativity, and material pleasures.

It’s a bit like using a well-written argument in an essay that lacks proper references—the core content is there, but the support system is too weak to uphold it effectively. (Speaking of which, if you're into academic writing, platforms like MyAssignmentHelp offer excellent resources and essay writing services that explain structuring arguments, which can sometimes be surprisingly helpful even in understanding logical frameworks in astrology.)

So, to summarize: while tatkaalik maitri adds value, it can’t override the debilitation of the dispositor. The strength of the house and aspects from other benefics will play a critical role in balancing the outcome.

Would love to hear others' perspectives on similar chart configurations!